1. DoorDex - Best Overall

Best for: DeFi traders, poker players, active crypto buyers, fast remittance

Why it's better than Paxful:

• Under 5 minutes from payment to wallet

• No seller drama — direct processing every time

• Transparent fees: 4.5% buy, 3.9% sell

• Loyalty Rewards System

• Wire, Zelle, Bank of America transfers

• Non-Custodial

The catch: Premium pricing. But here's the math: Paxful charges 1% platform fee + 5-10% seller markup = 6-11% total. DoorDex charges 4.5%. And you get it in 5 minutes instead of an hour.

Bonus free perks:

• DeFi MasterClass (12 videos on profitable strategies)

• Weekly newsletter with vetted yield opportunities

• Private Trading Community community

• VIP treatment for $10K+/month users

Who it's NOT for: Casual buyers doing $50-100 purchases occasionally. This is for traders moving real capital who need speed.

2. Binance P2P – Not Available in U.S

Best for: International buyers

The deal:

• 0% platform fees (sellers still mark up 2-8%)

• 300+ payment methods globally

• Huge liquidity = faster matching

• Binance escrow protection

The downsides:

• Still P2P (seller speed varies: 15-45 min average)

• KYC required

• You're trusting individual sellers

• Price shopping takes time

• Not Available  for U.S residenets

• Risk of banking restrictions

• Triangle Schemes

3. Kraken – Beginner Focused

Best for: Occasional Users

What works:

• Direct buy (no P2P seller needed)

• Lower fees than Coinbase (0.16-0.26%)

• Wire deposits same-day

• Good reputation and security

What doesn't:

• ACH still takes 7-10 days

• Limited instant payment options

• Higher spreads on instant buys

• Not actually peer-to-peer

• Custody of your funds

• Risks of Freezes and Blocks

4. LocalCoinSwap – Non-Custodial P2P

Best for: Privacy-focused, non-custodial trading

Highlights:

• You control your keys (non-custodial)

• Smart contract escrow

• 1% platform fee + 8% seller markup

• Multiple cryptocurrencies

Tradeoffs:

• Smaller liquidity pool

• 20-60 minute average trades

• Steeper learning curve

• Fewer payment methods than Binance

• Risks of Freezes and Blocks

• You're trusting individual sellers

5. Bisq – Maximum Privacy

Best for: Privacy maximalists only

What you get:

• Fully decentralized (no company, no servers)

• Zero KYC ever

• True peer-to-peer

What you sacrifice:

• Slow (1-4 hours typical)

• Low liquidity

• Complex setup

• Limited payment methods

• Potential involvement in illegal activities

• Restricted bank accounts

Which Platform Replaces Paxful Best?

For active traders who need capital access measured in minutes, not hours, premium speed platforms exist for a reason.

Stop waiting. Start trading.